Close

Member Login

Logging In
Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Signing up could earn you gear and it helps to keep offensive content off of our site.

NTSB Puts GA Safety on Most Wanted List

By Stephen Pope / Published: Nov 15, 2012
Rate it! or

The NTSB has once again included general aviation safety in its annual list of “most wanted safety improvements,” and in doing so the board lamented the fact that GA continues to have the highest accident rate within civil aviation including a fatality rate that has jumped by 25 percent in recent years.

The NTSB investigates about 1,500 accidents each year in general aviation involving more than 400 fatalities. In many cases, it finds that pilots did not have the “adequate knowledge, skills or recurrent training to fly safely, particularly in questionable weather conditions.” The board also said that sophisticated glass cockpit displays present a “new layer of complications for general aviation pilots. Not only are pilots dying due to human error and inadequate training, but also they are frequently transporting their families who suffer the same tragic fate.”

The Board noted that the GA accident rate is six times higher than for small commuter operators and about 40 times higher than for transport-category operators. And while the overall GA accident rate has remained about the same over the last 10 years, the fatal accident rate has increased by a whopping 25 percent.

“Pilots should be trained to use all available sources for weather information,” the NTSB said, “including the internet and satellites.” Also, they should train on flight simulators that are specific to the avionics they will be flying and be tested on the use of weather, instruments and glass cockpits.

Still, pilot error isn’t the only area of concern for GA safety. Aircraft mechanics should also be required to undergo recurrent training to keep them up to date with the best practices for inspecting and maintaining electrical systems, circuit breakers, and aged wiring, the board said.

The NTSB first put GA safety on its most wanted list last year. The only other aviation-related item on the list, which also includes safety initiatives for passenger vehicles, trains and buses, is airport surface operations.

Comments (2) Post a comment

All Comments

rtavan's picture

It's certainly appropriate for NTSB to want to improve GA safety. But to have "lamented the fact that GA continues to have the highest accident rate within civil aviation" is ridiculous. I hope it's a misquote. Of course, GA has the highest accident rate within civil aviation! It is at the bottom of the stack in terms of training, crew size and equipment. If GA did not have the highest accident rate, then another, better trained and equipped civil aviation service would have that unfortunate distinction and would be looking a lot worse than GA does now.

PAPilot's picture

Glass cockpit avionics are wonderful for keeping up with situational awareness and generally allowing a pilot to fly with greater confidence. Sadly, many pilots operate these systems with only the most basic knowledge of them to complete an uneventful flight, thereby requiring greater heads-down time to program them and creating distraction from the primary task of flying the aircraft. Once, I received an irate call from an FBO because I set the G1000 map orientation in a rental to north-up for my flight, and the pilot flying after me did not know how to reset it for track-up.

Pilotage and VOR navigation are rapidly becoming lost arts because students are routinely being taught to hit "direct to" and follow the straight pink line on the GPS screen. Due to the sensitive nature of financial constraints on the part of both students and flight schools, enough time is not allotted to ground instruction in running glass cockpits because it robs time from flying. Such instruction is often accomplished in the air while the mind of a student is rightly occupied with other matters. Then the pilot goes solo and ends up in a panic or gets lost when the screens do something unexpected and they can't get it back to displaying the GPS map.

I also find low-end (under $100k) simulators to be poorly set up for learning glass cockpit systems. I use one with an instructor for practicing instrument flight and, when necessary, keeping my instrument currency. While the controls are in the same place as an actual cockpit, the shape of some knobs are different, sometimes causing confusion by requiring that I visually look for the knob (in the dark) and verify that I have the right one before turning it. They also tend to have a lag time and don't work if I turn a knob faster than the computer system can keep up.

Of course, the airlines make sure their pilots are experts in the systems they fly. This is not a requirement for the GA population and the accident record shows it. The added complexity can become overwhelming when a flight does not go as planned. During such moments, responses that have not become ingrained and automatic during times of stress will be of little use during an emergency.

Top Rated

Your Comment
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use