Fatal Cirrus Accident Shows That Some Knowledge Doesn’t Translate

Helicopter pilot’s fixed-wing inexperience proved costly in a desert mountainside crash that killed four.

Peter Garrison

Monday, April 15, 2024 at 09:22 AM ET

Verified

An aerial view of a sunny day on Bryce Canyon in the Utah desert. [iStock]

Key Takeaways:

A fatal Cirrus SR20 crash in mountainous terrain was caused by a highly experienced helicopter pilot, with limited fixed-wing time, making critical errors including overloading the aircraft, flying at dangerously low airspeed, and underutilizing engine power in high-density altitude.
The pilot's ingrained helicopter flying habits likely contributed to his failure to apply correct fixed-wing climbing techniques (e.g., best rate-of-climb speed, full RPM), even as the stall warning alarm sounded continuously for several minutes before the crash.
The accident highlights the significant dangers of transferring operational habits between different aircraft types, such as helicopters and fixed-wing airplanes, underscoring the need for type-specific proficiency and understanding of flight dynamics.

See a mistake? Contact us.

On a warm day in late spring, four professional helicopter pilots rented a Cirrus SR20 in North Las Vegas, Nevada, for a fishing trip to Bryce Canyon, Utah. Of the four, only one had an airplane rating.

After taking off from North Las Vegas Airport (KVGT) and flying 60 miles, they landed at Mesquite, Nevada (67L), where they added 10 gallons of fuel. The pilot with the airplane rating, who had flown the first leg, now ceded the left front seat to one of his companions, evidently with the idea of giving him some flight instruction. He moved to the right seat, and they performed several touch-and-gos before continuing toward Bryce Canyon, 105 miles distant.