Register

A Closer Look

It’s common to auto-fill the alternate box with a nearby airport that meets legal weather and fuel requirements. But sometimes, a better alternate can be found nearby.

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • The pilot's initial alternate planning met legal minimums but not personal preferences, and the destination weather deteriorated rapidly, making non-precision approaches challenging due to limited aids and pilot errors.
  • After multiple missed approaches at the primary destination due to difficulty discerning visibility and maintaining approach discipline, the pilot had to carefully manage fuel and re-evaluate options.
  • Ultimately, the pilot successfully diverted to an *unplanned* alternate by creatively interpreting available approaches, underscoring the importance of thorough pre-flight alternate planning that extends beyond legal requirements and includes logistical considerations.
See a mistake? Contact us.

Alternates often get brushed off as an administrative task. If the weather’s good enough, you don’t legally need one under the ol’ 2000-3 rule of §91.169(b). Or, should one be required when filing that flight plan, it’s usually a nearby default with an ILS, so long as it meets the 600-2 rule, §91.169(c). This usually works out fine since you rarely divert. But if you do, it might help to look deeper, lest you miss out on a better way to escape the weather and get on the ground.

Plans A and B

Off you go eastbound to Jamestown, New York, in kind of a hurry—weather will get down to the bottom line, and you need a decent alternate that has a car so you can still make your business lunch. The good news is that standard ILS and LPV approaches await at KJHW, elevation 1723. The bad news is that those are reserved for Runway 25. Today’s TAF has winds favoring Runway 7 or 13, and those aren’t as well equipped; they have RNAV procedures with LNAV MDAs of 2120 and 2140 feet respectively. So stick with 7; its MDA is a tad lower and the runway’s longer. Ceilings and visibility will drop to 400-1 after 11 a.m. local. So you decide to shorten your first meeting at the office, knowing there’ll be no complaints. This allowed you to depart an hour ahead of time for the three-hour flight.

Ready to Sell Your Aircraft?

List your airplane on AircraftForSale.com and reach qualified buyers.

List Your Aircraft
AircraftForSale Logo | FLYING Logo
Pilot in aircraft
Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox.

SUBSCRIBE