Aviation Can’t Keep Learning Safety Lessons the Hard Way

Ignored warnings, known risks, and a tragedy that never should have happened.

Tim Lilley

Thursday, January 29, 2026 at 08:00 AM ET

Verified

Edited By:

Ryan Ewing

NTSB investigators inspect wreckage of CRJ-700. [Credit: NTSB]

Key Takeaways:

The author, Tim Lilley, whose son died in a preventable aviation accident, asserts that the tragedy was a predictable outcome of a culture that normalized unsafe acts and failed to address known risks, rather than a single mistake.
He emphasizes that a 2008 NTSB recommendation for full ADS-B (Out and In) implementation in congested airspace, if fully adopted, could have prevented the accident, highlighting a failure to act on known safety gaps.
While acknowledging some post-accident improvements (e.g., airspace closure, ATC investment), the author stresses the need for proactive, data-driven regulation over reactive measures and urges Congress to pass the ROTOR Act to mandate proven safety technology.

See a mistake? Contact us.

Tim Lilley, the father of American Airlines Flight 5342 First Officer Sam Lilley, is a retired U.S. Army Black Hawk pilot and current commercial jet captain.

I have flown military helicopters and commercial jets for most of my adult life. I have come to understand risk. I understand complex systems. I also understand, in a way no parent ever should, what it means when those systems fail.