I was struck by what I believe was an omission in the commentary in “Real-World VFR into IMC” (February 2021). Prior to my instrument rating, the procedure upon entering IMC I had committed to memory was a variation of aviate, navigate and communicate: Trust instruments completely, turn 180 degrees while maintaining level flight to get out of IMC, declare an emergency. That third step was even an oral exam question for my PPL. (Question: Is it an emergency if you inadvertently fly into IMC? Answer: Yes.)
Neither of the VFR pilots in the article completed steps 2 or 3, though the commentary focuses on step 2. The “VFR-only Private Pilot” would have benefited greatly from declaring an emergency to the controller putting him through the clouds as soon as it technically was one. Based on his account, that NASA report was quite nearly an NTSB one.
