Register

Dissecting a Tragedy in the Third Dimension

There's quite a difference between simulated IFR and the real thing.

The difference between simulated instrument flying and the real thing—especially when compounded by darkness—is difficult for novice instrument pilots to imagine. [iStock]
Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • A private pilot crashed during a night instrument approach to Steamboat Springs after unexpectedly encountering weather conditions below minimums, despite initial VFR forecasts.
  • The pilot significantly deviated from the published approach, descending below required altitudes and prematurely initiating a missed approach turn without climbing, leading to a collision with nearby terrain while attempting to retract landing gear.
  • The accident suggests the pilot was unprepared for real-world IMC and unexpected balked approaches, possibly due to a reliance on autopilot and practicing in VMC, leading to unsteady control and poor decision-making under pressure.
See a mistake? Contact us.

On a December evening, a turboprop Piper Meridian climbed out of Cody, Wyoming, for a 300-mile flight to Steamboat Springs, Colorado. The flight must have been a pleasant one for the private pilot, 42, an orthopedic surgeon who lived in Steamboat Springs. He had a 40-knot tailwind at 25,000 feet and made a groundspeed of more than 300 knots. When he left Cody, Steamboat was reporting 4,500 broken and 7 miles. Every reporting station along the route was VFR. The forecast for his arrival called for VFR conditions with some light snow in the vicinity and some mountain obscuration to the east.

It was dark when he approached Steamboat Springs. Cleared for the RNAV (GPS)-E approach for Runway 32 at Bob Adams Field (KSBS), he began his descent 20 minutes out, turned eastward at the initial approach fix, HABRO, and then northward at MABKY intersection.

Peter Garrison

Peter Garrison taught himself to use a slide rule and tin snips, built an airplane in his backyard, and flew it to Japan. He began contributing to FLYING in 1968, and he continues to share his columns, ""Technicalities"" and ""Aftermath,"" with FLYING readers.

Ready to Sell Your Aircraft?

List your airplane on AircraftForSale.com and reach qualified buyers.

List Your Aircraft
AircraftForSale Logo | FLYING Logo
Pilot in aircraft
Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox.

SUBSCRIBE