Flying magazine's John King and AOPA Pilot's Rod Machado debate the merits of the ACS.Tracy Boulian; David Ahntholz
Key Takeaways:
The Airman Certification Standards (ACS) were introduced to enhance pilot safety by integrating knowledge, risk management, and practical skills, moving beyond the perceived shortcomings of the prior Practical Test Standards (PTS).
Proponents believe the ACS will save lives by fostering systematic risk management habits and making pilot training more relevant and effective, providing objective standards for evaluating real-world flying scenarios.
Critics argue the ACS is overly complex, significantly increasing the length of previous standards, and lacks sufficient empirical evidence to support claims of accident reduction or reduced training costs and time.
A primary concern among skeptics is that testing risk management is inherently subjective, potentially compromising the practical test's objectivity, and that the ACS misplaces emphasis from skill-based errors, which past studies suggest are a more significant cause of general aviation accidents.
John King started King Schools Inc., with his wife, Martha, in a spare bedroom of their home. Today, the school operates out of a dedicated complex in San Diego, California, that includes a video and software production facility. John and Martha have shared flying and teaching aviation for more than 50 years.