Close

Member Login

Logging In
Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Signing up could earn you gear and it helps to keep offensive content off of our site.

Accident Report: One Student Pilot's Reckless Decision

By Peter Garrison / Published: Oct 24, 2011
Rate it! 100% or 0%

(October 2011) It's an old story. As old as the Greeks, in fact, though it has been retold many times and in many versions. Its erotic, pathetic, heroic and cautionary elements receive different emphases from authors with different axes to grind. In brief, Leander was a youth who lived on one shore of the Hellespont, the narrow strait that separates Greece from Asia Minor. He became the lover of a priestess of Aphrodite — her name was Hero, pronounced more like hair-oh — who dwelt on the other shore. He would visit her nightly, swimming across the channel while she set out a lantern to guide him. One night it was stormy, and Leander drowned.

The worldly-wise Lord Byron once swam the Hellespont in Leander’s honor. He later complained that, while the brave Greek youth won eternal fame, all he got for his pains was a cold.

What moral should we draw from the story of Leander? That love cannot, in fact, conquer all? That youthful rashness and rough water go ill together? Perhaps something more general, about recklessness and any sort of dangerous activity.

A 21-year-old Alabama man began taking flying lessons on Oct. 30. He got his student certificate a week later, at that point reporting six hours of flight experience. In his application for the third-class medical, he did not mention that he had used a prescription antidepressant when he was 18, and had then been treated with a series of other medications for a diagnosis of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, a recently discovered ailment mainly of disruptive or unfocused schoolboys. For the past few months he had been taking daily doses of Adderall, an amphetamine “study drug” with the paradoxical property of stimulating the enervated while calming the overstimulated.

The student pilot pursued his flying lessons assiduously. He made his first solo flight in the pattern on Dec. 20 and his second on the 23rd. An instructor endorsed his logbook for solo flying within 25 miles of the home airport, with limitations: daytime only, no passengers, wind not to exceed 10 knots, maximum crosswind six knots, ceiling above 2,300 feet and visibility no less than six miles. The instructor also explained these limitations to him verbally.

At this point he had logged 26 hours, a quarter of them at night. He had not yet received any cross-country instruction.

On Dec. 23, the student pilot bought himself a 37-year-old, recently annualed Cherokee 140.

The evening of Dec. 24 was forecast to be stormy, with wind and rain. An instructor, observing the student fueling his newly acquired airplane a little after noon, told him that he “needed to be through flying for the day” because of the weather. The student agreed and said that he would put the airplane away.

Comments (7) Post a comment

All Comments

BillFishJr's picture

i am a quiet pilot. i do not criticize other pilots - spending too much time criticizing myself.
but i wish i had an answer to a question i have.
at KSAN they had a restaurant right next door to JimsAir and i was sitting with my wife having coffee waiting for the usually "low night and early morning clouds along the coast" to break up to at least special VFR.
Man came out of the restaurant so completely totally blitzed he actually stumbled at one point. i even said to my wife - i hope the pilot has a barf bag for his passenger as this guy climbed into a B-58 Baron. Seconds later he's in the left seat and minutes later he departs IFR.
Here is my question. What - if anything - am i supposed to do about it?
Seriously. Is this really 'my business'? and IF i call someone - WHO am i supposed to call?
Reading about this accident really brought back the memory.
What would YOU have done?

chalete's picture

Nothing. If he was irresponsible enough to fly pretty drunk, it is his life.

dljone3's picture

BillFishJr good question. Definitely don't ignore something like this. As fellow pilots we have a responsibility to report activities such as this. At the very least you would be helping the pilot in question. More importantly you may be helping anyone else in the air near this guy. If you are at a towered airport, contact the tower and report what you saw. If you are at an uncontrolled airport, contact the tower or ATC facility which has controlling authority over the area. Thanks for caring. We need more pilots like you.

jefferyk1's picture

Billfishjr,
What if later you heard of him crashing into a house or building and killing others? I think we should report drunk flying the same as you would report a drunk driver in a car. Write down the N number, description, departure, etc and call the FAA, ATC, tower, ANYBODY who can at least make an effort. I know a guy who decided one day to "weave" in/out of sailboats in Biscayne Bay Miami and the FAA was waiting on him when he landed, thanks to numerous calls from boaters who got his N number and a description. He was not drinking, but the same idea could be applied. Might be easier to live with yourself knowing you tried if he killed someone. Just my 2 cents.

hotwings's picture

Strongly disagree with chalete on this one. If the gentleman came stumbling out of a bar and got in his car, I would call the authorities with a description... It's anonymous and it might safe an innocent persons life.

Imagine arriving or departing KSAN with this bone-head in the near vicinity. No thank you.

Billfishjr the answer to your question is... contact any aerodrome personal and report the incident. It is your business... It's incumbent on you as a responsible person to do something, if only to mention the Baron's identifier to ATC on your initial call up.

In my part of the world believe it or not... one might be considered compliant or partially responsible for not doing so.

Just saying

iused2fly's picture

Another gem from Peter Garrison.

All the training and admonishments from his instructor couldn't stop this young man from killing himself. He showed a pattern of contempt for the rules of the air, ignored the safety advice of both his instructor an his girl friend. Was it rapture of the air that made him think he was bulletproof, or just the bull-headed nature of dome young men? It reminds me of that great aviation maxim: there are old pilots and bold pilots, but no old, bold pilots.

The lesson for the rest of us? A license to fly is an opportunity for a lifetime of continuous learning. No private course can teach or address all the potential pitfalls and risks a pilot will encounter in the air. Hopefully the death of this young man will have a positive impact on other impulsive or foolhardy student pilots in the future.

Douglas M
Surrey, British Columbia

cris's picture

I have ADHD and suspect a greater correlation of too much money/pilot morbidity than ADHD. I am fortunate that part of my primary training was an assignment to determine the top five ways pilots kill themselves (and their family-friends) in aircraft.

Top Rated

Your Comment
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use