Close

Member Login

Logging In
Invalid username or password.
Incorrect Login. Please try again.

not a member? sign-up now!

Signing up could earn you gear and it helps to keep offensive content off of our site.

Can Humpback Whales Help Helicopters?

By Pia Bergqvist / Published: Feb 02, 2012
Rate it! 100% or 0%

Popular belief says the cleaner the leading edge of an airfoil is, the more efficient it becomes. But scientists are now looking into how strategically placed bumps on the main rotors of helicopters may boost performance. Researchers at the German Aerospace Center (DLR) in Göttingen, Germany, claim they got the idea of using the concept on helicopters from humpback whales, which are able to attain great speed under water with help from their oversized, bumpy-edged pectoral fins. “Research has shown that these bumps cause stalling to occur significantly later underwater and increase buoyancy,” said Holger Mai from the DLR Institute of Aeroelasticity.

This concept has been used on airplane wings with vortex generators (VGs), which effectively delay the separation of airflow over the wing. This change in the airflow around the airfoil can improve control surface effectiveness and decreases the stall speed, depending on the installation.  

But the benefits for helicopters may be significantly different.

Kai Richter from the DLR Institute of Aerodynamics and Flow Technology hopes the addition of Leading-Edge Vortex Generators (LEVoGs for short) will decrease the dynamic stall of the aft moving main rotor blade during maneuvers and fast forward flight, which diminishes maneuverability and speed and causes unwanted vibration. If the concept proves successful, Richter says the rubber pieces could easily be retrofitted to existing main rotor blades at little expense. He also claims LEVoG contours could be milled into the propeller blades for new helicopters.

After conducting wind tunnel tests on the concept, DLR is now in the process of flight-testing LEVoGs using a Messerschmitt-Bölkow-Blohm Bo105 helicopter with 186 rubber LEVoGs attached to each of the four main rotor blades. The purpose of the initial flight tests is to prove the safety of the concept and so far the new technology looks promising. “The pilots have already noticed a difference in the behavior of the rotor blades,” Richter said. The next flight-test phase will record the effects of the LEVoGs.

 

Interested in winning a free iPad? How about one of ten $50 gift certificates to Flying's online shop? Like us on Facebook and enter to win!

Comments (5) Post a comment

All Comments

wjboczany's picture

That is why I always have a rule that "NO ONE GETS IN OR OUT OF THE AIRPLANE" when the prop is running...PERIOD and NO EXCEPTIONS....PERIOD!

airsteve172's picture

After reading the article 'Can Humpback Whales Help Helicopters?', I would tend to be in complete agreement with wjb0czany's comment, but only while under the influence of excessive amounts of adult beverages! ;)

Herm222's picture

Fascinating article with interesting prospect for helicopter blade efficiency; I am sure the testing will provide a realistic model for engineering development. The analogy to Humpback whale performance leaves me skeptical, however. Unlike porpoises and killer whales, who are carnivorous predators, humpback whales are plankton feeders, bulky vegetarians who have little need, and almost no record of the necessity for speed. Years ago we studied the skin, using non-destructive testing, for several species in order to understand any speed potential. Humpback skin was noticeably rougher, and more susceptible to having attached growths, compared to the remarkably smooth skin of killer whales and porpoises, who also gave no evidence of fouling so common on material exposed to seawater. Fouling extracts a severe speed penalty to ships, as most skippers know quite well.

ML's picture

@Herm222
Two observations: 1) Caeteris paribus, there would seem to always be an evolutionary advantage to being more efficient; it doesn't have to be about speed. 2) If it is about speed, helicopters don't generally fly as fast as fixed-wing aircraft.

Christian's picture

Is that Göttlingen near Hamblurg?

Top Rated

Your Comment
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use